These days, it remains a dominant hypothesis among people alarmed by current ecological trends that the real problem we face is “consumerism,” which, in this familiar formulation, is the individual-level mental disorder that adds up, at the collective level, to “consumer culture.”
If this “consumerism” hypothesis is the best one available, how, then, are we to interpret this “nationally representative sample of 2,003 U.S. residents interviewed between April 13-16, 2021”?:
The answer, of course, is that you can’t. This evidence is not compatible with the “consumer culture” hypothesis. Even here in the good ol’ US of A, people are not a pack of intractably stupid shopaholics who insist on preserving the status quo.
Will this basic point penetrate the environmentalist community? Almost certainly not. They themselves are pretty wasted on their own dangerous mix of social-scientific laziness and “I’m green” hubris.
But one can still say it: Physicians, heal thyselves. “Consumerism” and “consumer culture” are phantasms.